in , , , ,

Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included)

The Cat House Meow
The Holiday Issue · Nº 11
46
47
The Holiday Issue · Nº 11
Wellness & Lifestyle · An Investigation

Pass the Squash,Tell the Truth

Candlelight, a plant-forward feast for every guest, a slow-smoked bird for those who crave one, and the real history behind the holiday, Moors included.

Alix Purr, Cat House Meow Thanksgiving feature
Editor’s Letter

Every November the same picture comes out of storage: smiling Pilgrims in buckled hats, nameless “Indians” bearing corn, a golden turkey glowing at the center of a long table. It’s a lovely picture. It’s also mostly a nineteenth-century greeting card.

This year, we’re doing Thanksgiving the Cat House way. We feed everybody: the vegan niece, the vegetarian best friend, the uncle who swears he “doesn’t do vegetables,” and the guest who’s watching their heart. And we tell the story straight. The true version has more people in it, more places, more pain and more hope than the one we were handed in grade school.

Pour something warm. Tap through the comic. Build your table. Smoke a bird or don’t. And if you’re reading this somewhere far from family, scroll to the end, because there’s a seat for you.

Alix Purr

Alix PurrHostess energy, fully lit. House rules: everyone eats, nobody gets judged, and dessert is never rushed.
Interactive comic · tap or swipe

“Wait… That’s Not How It Happened?”

Madame Whiskerstein walks Kit, our very curious intern, through four centuries in nine panels. Tap the panel, use your arrow keys, or swipe.

Panel 1 of 9
Keeping it real

The 1621 Feast, Without the Frosting

Here is what the record actually supports. In the fall of 1621, roughly fifty surviving English colonists at Plymouth held a harvest celebration. Only two written accounts of it exist, and the main one is a single paragraph by Edward Winslow. About ninety Wampanoag men came with their leader Ousamequin (often called Massasoit). Historians still debate whether they were invited or arrived because they heard gunfire from the hunt. The Wampanoag brought five deer, and the event ran about three days.

Nobody called it “Thanksgiving.” For the Puritans, a thanksgiving was a day of prayer and often fasting, not a party. Harvest feasts were ordinary on both sides of the Atlantic. Wampanoag communities had held harvest ceremonies for thousands of years, and still do; the Aquinnah Wampanoag’s Cranberry Day is one of them.

The 1621 meal was diplomacy with a side of venison, not a holiday. Ousamequin had made a political decision to ally with the newcomers after an epidemic had devastated his people.

The alliance lasted about a generation. As English settlement spread, pressure on Wampanoag land grew, and in 1675 Ousamequin’s son Metacom led what the English named King Philip’s War. It was one of the deadliest wars per capita in American history, and it shattered the Native nations of southern New England.

The holiday we know came much later. Magazine editor Sarah Josepha Hale, who also wrote “Mary Had a Little Lamb,” spent decades lobbying presidents for a national Thanksgiving. In 1863, in the middle of the Civil War, Abraham Lincoln finally proclaimed one. The Pilgrim-and-Indian origin story was attached afterward, as the old accounts resurfaced and the country went looking for a unifying myth.

Alix Purr
Alix Purr

Alix PurrHigh above the city, and still the best view in the room. Tap any photo to see it full screen.

✦ ✦ ✦
The investigation

The Moors Question: What’s Real, What’s Not

Scroll social media this time of year and you’ll run into a stack of “hidden history” posts about the Moors and Thanksgiving. Some are flat-out false. Others point toward a story that is real, and stranger than the meme. We pulled the files. Tap the blacked-out lines to declassify them.

NO EVIDENCE

Claim #1: “The Moors were America’s original people.”

This idea mostly traces to the Moorish Science Temple of America, founded in the early 1900s, and later sovereign-citizen-style groups. Archaeologists and fact-checkers have found no evidence for it. The mounds and earthworks often cited as “Moorish pyramids” were built by Native American societies, and the genetic and archaeological record ties the first Americans to ancient migrations from Asia.

NO EVIDENCE

Claim #2: “Thanksgiving secretly celebrates a massacre of Moors, and ‘turkey’ means Turks.”

The meme says the feast commemorates Spain’s defeat of the Moors. No historical document connects Plymouth’s 1621 harvest, Lincoln’s 1863 proclamation, or any colonial thanksgiving to a victory over the Moors. The bird’s English name likely comes from a mix-up: Europeans confused the American bird with the guinea fowl, which reached Europe through Ottoman (“Turkish”) trade routes.

DOCUMENTED

Finding #1: A Moroccan crossed America nearly a century before the Pilgrims.

His name was Mustafa Azemmouri, from the Moroccan port of Azemmour. Enslaved, he was renamed Estevanico by his Spanish owner Andrés Dorantes. He was one of only four survivors of the doomed 1528 Narváez expedition, which landed in Florida. He walked across the Gulf Coast and the Southwest, learned Native languages, and served as a guide until his death at Hawikuh, in present-day New Mexico, in 1539. He is widely regarded as the first African-born explorer of North America.

DOCUMENTED

Finding #2: Squanto’s road to Plymouth ran through Moorish Spain.

Ever wonder why Tisquantum (Squanto) spoke English? In 1614 the English captain Thomas Hunt kidnapped him with about two dozen other Native men and sailed them to Málaga, Spain, to sell as slaves. Málaga had been a great city of the Muslim Emirate of Granada until Catholic forces took it in 1487. Local friars took custody of some captives. Tisquantum made his way to England, learned the language, and eventually sailed home, only to find his Patuxet village wiped out by epidemic. The Pilgrims built Plymouth on its ruins.

DOCUMENTED

Finding #3: The “first” thanksgiving was Spanish, and Spain was shaped by the Moors.

Fifty-six years before Plymouth, on September 8, 1565, Pedro Menéndez de Avilés and hundreds of Spanish settlers landed at St. Augustine, Florida, held a Mass of thanksgiving and shared a meal with the Seloy, a Timucua people. That Spain had come out of nearly eight centuries of Moorish rule in Al-Andalus (711–1492). Moorish farmers spread crops across Iberia, including rice, citrus, sugarcane, almonds and eggplant, and Spanish ships later carried many of them to the Americas. A few of those flavors are on your plate this Thursday.

The verdict: The Moors didn’t invent Thanksgiving, and the holiday isn’t a coded victory party. But a Moroccan explorer, a kidnapped Patuxet man sold in a former Moorish city, and a Spanish thanksgiving in Florida are all part of how this continent’s story really unfolded. The truth doesn’t need a conspiracy. It’s interesting enough already.

Tap to flip

Five Things Your Textbook Fudged

THE PICTUREPilgrims wore black, buckles and tall hats.
They mostly wore colorful everyday clothes and saved black for Sundays and formal portraits. The buckles came from 19th-century illustrators.
THE PICTURETurkey was the star of the first feast.
The record mentions “fowl” (possibly ducks or geese) and five deer from the Wampanoag. Shellfish and corn were probably there too. Turkey is possible but unconfirmed.
THE PICTUREThere was pumpkin pie.
Almost certainly not. The colonists had no butter and wheat for crusts, and no ovens to bake them in. Pumpkins and squash, though? Very likely.
THE PICTUREIt became a yearly tradition.
It was a one-time event. The national holiday came in 1863, and in 1941 Congress fixed it to the fourth Thursday of November.
THE PICTUREEveryone celebrates it.
Since 1970, many Native people have gathered on Cole’s Hill in Plymouth every Thanksgiving for the National Day of Mourning, started after Wamsutta Frank James’s speech was cancelled.
Overhead Thanksgiving table with many dishes
The Modern TableAbundant, candlelit, a little indulgent, and welcoming to every kind of appetite.
Photo via Pexels
✦ ✦ ✦
Interactive · build your table

Who’s Coming to Dinner?

You don’t have to be vegan or vegetarian to cook for someone who is. The trick is a menu where most dishes work for everyone, so nobody’s stuck with a dinner roll and a side of guilt. Tap your guests below and watch the menu sort itself.

Tap a guest to start.
The recipes · tap to open, adjust servings, tick off ingredients as you go

The Cat House Thanksgiving Menu

Everything below is built to please mixed company. Change the serving count and the quantities recalculate. Tap an ingredient to check it off while you shop or cook, which is something a printed page can’t do for you.

Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included) 1

VeganGF

Wild Rice & Cranberry Stuffed Acorn Squash

The vegan centerpiece that steals the show · 1 hr 10 min

Serves 4
  • acorn squash, halved and seeded
  • wild rice blend, cooked in veg broth
  • dried cranberries
  • toasted pecans, chopped
  • shallot, minced
  • celery ribs, diced
  • fresh sage, chopped
  • olive oil
  • maple syrup
  • Salt, pepper, pinch of cinnamon
  1. Heat oven to 400°F. Brush squash halves with half the oil, season, and roast cut-side down 30–35 min until tender.
  2. Sauté shallot and celery in remaining oil 5 min. Stir in rice, cranberries, pecans, sage and cinnamon.
  3. Flip squash, fill generously, drizzle with maple, and bake 10 more minutes.
  4. Finish with extra sage and a few pomegranate seeds if you’re feeling fancy.
Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included) 2

Vegan

Mushroom-Lentil Loaf, Maple-Balsamic Glaze

Sliceable, savory, and the meat-eaters go back for seconds · 1 hr 20 min

Serves 6
  • cooked brown or green lentils
  • cremini mushrooms, finely chopped
  • yellow onion, diced
  • carrots, grated
  • garlic cloves
  • rolled oats (GF if needed)
  • ground flax + 5 tbsp water
  • tamari
  • thyme + 1 tsp smoked paprika
  • Glaze: ketchup, 2 tbsp balsamic, 1 tbsp maple
  1. Mix flax and water and let it gel 10 min. Heat oven to 375°F and line a loaf pan.
  2. Sauté onion, mushrooms, carrot and garlic until the mushrooms release their liquid and it cooks off, about 10 min.
  3. Pulse half the lentils with the oats in a food processor. Combine everything and press into the pan.
  4. Spread the glaze on top and bake 45–50 min. Rest 15 min before slicing; it firms up as it cools.
Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included) 3

VeganGF

Crispy Maple Brussels Sprouts with Pecans

Converts sprout haters every single year · 30 min

Serves 6
  • Brussels sprouts, halved
  • olive oil
  • maple syrup
  • balsamic vinegar
  • pecans
  • Flaky salt, black pepper, chili flakes
  1. Roast sprouts cut-side down with oil, salt and pepper at 425°F for 20–25 min, until deeply browned.
  2. Toss with maple, balsamic and pecans and return to the oven for 3 minutes. Serve hot.
Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included) 4

VeganGF

Garlic Cauliflower-Potato Mash & Mushroom Gravy

Creamy without the butter brick · 35 min

Serves 6
  • Yukon Gold potatoes
  • small head cauliflower
  • head roasted garlic
  • good olive oil
  • unsweetened oat milk, warm
  • Gravy: mushrooms, 2 cups veg broth, 2 tbsp cornstarch, 1 tbsp tamari, thyme
  1. Boil potatoes and cauliflower until very tender, then drain well. Mash with roasted garlic, oil and oat milk, and season.
  2. Gravy: brown the mushrooms hard, add broth and tamari, simmer 5 min, and thicken with cornstarch stirred into a splash of cold water.
Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included) 5

Vegetarian

Butternut Three-Cheese Mac

For the vegetarians (and literally everyone else) · 45 min

Serves 8
  • cavatappi or elbows
  • roasted butternut squash, puréed
  • sharp cheddar, grated
  • Gruyère, grated
  • Parmesan (vegetarian rennet)
  • milk
  • Nutmeg, Dijon, panko and sage for the top
  1. Cook the pasta 2 min short of al dente.
  2. Warm the milk with the squash purée, then melt in the cheeses off the heat with a little Dijon and nutmeg. The squash replaces half the usual butter and flour roux.
  3. Fold in the pasta, top with panko and sage, and bake at 375°F for 20 min.

Heads up: many Parmesans use animal rennet, so check the label if your vegetarian guest is strict.

Pass the Squash, Tell the Truth: A Vegan Thanksgiving & the Real History (Moors Included) 6

Vegan

Maple Pumpkin Pie, Coconut Whip

Silky and dairy-free, with no “vegan pie” disclaimer needed · 1 hr + chill

Serves 8
  • vegan pie crust (most store-bought are)
  • pumpkin purée
  • full-fat coconut milk
  • maple syrup
  • cornstarch
  • pumpkin pie spice + 1 tsp vanilla
  • Topping: chilled coconut cream whipped with a little maple
  1. Heat oven to 350°F. Blend all filling ingredients until smooth and pour into the crust.
  2. Bake 55–60 min until the edges set but the center still jiggles slightly.
  3. Cool completely, then chill at least 4 hours or overnight. Top with whip.

Alix Purr

Alix PurrPlant-forward, flavor-first, and never apologizing for either.
For the turkey table

Low & Slow: A Healthier Smoked Turkey

If a bird is happening at your house, smoking it is one of the leaner ways to get there. The classic roast leans on butter under the skin, butter basting and a pan of drippings turned into gravy. Smoking swaps all that for time, low heat, aromatics and a good marinade. Fat renders out and drips away, the meat stays juicy, and the flavor comes from wood smoke, not a stick of butter.

The juicy-bird marinade (lower sodium)

  • 4 cups unsweetened apple cider + 2 cups water
  • Juice and zest of 2 oranges and 1 lemon
  • 1 head garlic, smashed; a big handful each of rosemary, thyme and sage
  • 1 tbsp black peppercorns, 1 tbsp smoked paprika, 2 bay leaves
  • Just ¼ cup kosher salt, about half a typical brine. The citrus and herbs carry the flavor.

Submerge the thawed bird in a food-safe bag or container and refrigerate 12–24 hours. For extra insurance, inject a cup of the strained marinade into the breasts and thighs. Pat completely dry, rub with a little olive oil, pepper, paprika and garlic, and rest it uncovered in the fridge for a few hours so the skin crisps.

The smoke

  1. Spatchcock it (remove the backbone and flatten). It cooks faster and more evenly, so the breast stays moist.
  2. Use mild fruitwoods: apple, cherry or pecan. Hickory and mesquite can overpower poultry.
  3. Keep a water pan in the smoker for moisture, and mop with warm apple cider every hour instead of butter.
  4. Don’t stuff a smoked bird. Bake the stuffing separately (see the squash above).
  5. Go by a thermometer, not the clock: 165°F in the thickest part of the breast and the innermost thigh.
  6. Rest 30 minutes, tented loosely. For the leanest plate, slide the skin off before serving; most of the saturated fat lives there.
Interactive · smoke-time estimator

—
This is an estimate. Wind, weather and your smoker all change it, so pull the bird when the thermometer says 165°F, not when the clock does.
Food-safety note: USDA guidance favors birds of about 12 lb or less for smoking, so the meat moves through the bacterial “danger zone” quickly. For a bigger crowd, smoke two smaller birds or a bone-in breast and legs separately.
For our bird lovers: we usually keep no opinion on what’s on your plate. But if you’re asking, we’d gently suggest skipping the meat if you can.
No pressure. We love you either way. 🧡
A family holding hands around a Thanksgiving table
The Real Main CourseThe people around the table.
Photo via Pexels
After the plates are cleared

The Couch Hour

You know the moment. The candles are low, the pie is half gone, someone’s asleep in the recliner, and the dishwasher hums like a lullaby. In my house, that’s when the phones come out. My niece and I have a ritual: we curl up and scroll Meow Movies together until someone yells about leftovers. Then I sneak a look through Meow Gallery to see who’s new and who looked especially radiant this month.

Before all that, though, we do one thing at the table. Everyone names one thing they’re grateful for. It sounds corny, it isn’t, and it can be digital too:

Drop something in the gratitude jar

Type what you’re thankful for and watch it land. It stays on your screen only; nothing is saved or sent.

Meow Movies · Members’ Premiere

Tonight’s Screening: Alix Purr

Dim the lights and press play. Members get the whole film. Everyone else gets a taste.

Alix Purr on Meow Movies

Preview
Play the preview
To be continued…

The rest is for members.

Join The Cat House Meow for Alix’s full film, every Meow Movie and every Meow Gallery set. Every membership also helps feed animals.

Join NowAlready a member? Log in

Alix PurrNow showing on Meow Movies

Alix Purr
Pumpkin pie being sliced

Alix PurrSave room for dessert. Trust us. Pie photo: Element5 Digital via Pexels

A seat for you

If You Have Family, Go Be With Them.

Hug them. Argue about the stuffing. Tell them the real story of 1621 over dessert. Being with the people who love you is the whole point.

And if you don’t have family this year, whether by loss, distance, or a door that closed, we see you. Our doors are open, and not just on Thanksgiving. They’re open all year round, for you.

Pull up a chair. You’re family here.

Want to help us feed people and animals all year? Visit The Cat House Meow Foundation.

The Centerfold

Alix Purr, Unfolded

Tap the cover to open the gatefold.

Alix Purr
Nº 11The Centerfold
Alix Purr
Alix Purr
The Holiday IssueAlix
Purr
Open ⟷
Contact sheet · tap any frame

In This Story

    What do you think?

    648.9k Points
    Upvote Downvote
    Justheadcat

    AUTHOR: The Cat House Magazine

    Cat House Meow Magazine is the flagship publication of Cat House — where investigative journalism, science, wellness, and luxury lifestyle collide under one philosophy: pleasure with purpose. Meet our Cat House Kittens, the models and brand ambassadors bringing each story to life, explore more on Cat House Live, and discover how every story fuels The Cat House Foundation's mission for animal welfare and community good.

    Leave a Reply

    alixpurr1

    alixpurr1